Spalding University Athletics

Career Honors
- 2016 SLIAC First Team All-Conference
- 2015 SLIAC Second Team All-Conference
- 2014 SLIAC Honorable Mention
- 2013 SLIAC Newcomer of the Year
- 2013 SLIAC First Team All-Conference

2016 Season
McAfee appeared in 34 games earning SLIAC First Team All-Conference honors.  McAfee made 117 plate appearances with a batting average of .378 and 19 RBIs for the season.  Alyssa highlighted her season going 4-for-5 with three RBIs and two runs scored in SU's victory over Bay Path.

2015 Season
McAfee appeared in 29 games earning SLIAC Second Team All-Conference honors. McAfee made 104 plate appearances hitting .274 with 16 RBIs for the season. Alyssa highlighted her season going 3-for-3 with three RBIs and three runs scored in SU’s 13-1 victory over Principia. 

2014 Season
McAfee appeared in all forty games and finished the season with a .371 batting average. McAfee led the team in hits (56), stolen bases (9), and tallied a conference leading seven triples. Alyssa recorded a season-high three hits on five separate occasions, and drove in a season-high four RBIs in a 15-0 win over New Rochelle. McAfee also appeared on the mound eight times during the season, posting a 4-2 record.

2013 Season
In her first season as a pitcher for the Lady Eagles, Alyssa McAfee started 11 games earning a 5-4 record including one shutout game. She finished the season with a 4.79 ERA, a 2.09 strikeout per game average and 17 total strikeouts on the season. McAfee ended the season with a .354 batting average through 113 at bats and recorded 40 hits, 25 runs, 24 RBIs, and4 homeruns. She finished the season with 3 triples which ranked her third in the SLIAC. On April 6, 2013, McAfee held MacMurry College to 2 hits and struck out 3 as the Lady Eagles won 8-0; earning McAfee her fourth win of the season. As a freshman, McAfee received 1st Team All-SLIAC honors.